Halvor again (spoiler)

[carborundum]

Hi folks,

I'm struggling to finish a bit of a quest...

I've found Halvor in Remgard and he wants bones, long ones. I've not yet found a creature that drops anything other than a generic bone. Is it time to tell him I give up, or is there somewhere I should go camping?

[rijackson741]

Just give him generic ones

[carborundum]

Thanks!
I've tried my whole inventory of fifty now, and it's just a constant

"How about these two?"
"Nope. That won't work. Could you find some longer ones?"

Perseverance?

[Zukero]

You should start to notice a pattern in his behavior....

[carborundum]

Hmmm, so far I only noticed he checks every actual bone. After a while I could no longer suggest any more to him, so my collection had been completely rejected!
I'll go get some more bones and not spam him quite so quickly

[Firefly84]

Hmmm, so far I only noticed he checks every actual bone. After a while I could no longer suggest any more to him, so my collection had been completely rejected!
I'll go get some more bones and not spam him quite so quickly

Ever tried another option than giving him bones?

[Antison]

sometimes two parties in an negotiation simply just have to walk away and agree to disagree.

[carborundum]

...or it's the rat tails all over again
Cheers! Still. I levelled to 44 on Mountain Brutes, so it wasn't all for nothing!

[rijackson741]

I'm inclined to add another reply to some of his dialogues, that only triggers after 20 tails / bones etc: "punch Halvor in the face, and leave" . Of course, then he will not be so friendly next time

[Zukero]

He is punchable indeed. Just like I wanted him to be. I hope it's worth it...